Tobold's Blog
Tuesday, September 09, 2008
Spore Review

Spore is the best 4X space game (eXplore, eXpand, eXploit, and eXterminate) since the original Master of Orion. It revives that flagging genre by making it easily accessible, real-time, with intuitive controls, removing the micromanagement, and making it very, very personal. Instead of your various fleets battling the AI's various fleets, your only control one space ship, followed by a few allies. You still beat the AI's various fleets, because your ship is more powerful, and just like a MMO avatar simply resurrects when destroyed. In Spore your space ship is *you*, whatever you do, wherever you want to do it, you first need to fly your space ship there. Oh, and Spore also comes with 4 mini-games for children before that space phase, covering the cell, creature, tribe, and civilization stages. But those stages are simplistic, easy, and short, and ultimately without consequences.

The game starts with the cell stage, where you steer an amoeba through an seemingly endless ocean, eating food and trying not to get eaten. You start out having a mouth to eat, eyes to see, and flagella to move. Pretty soon you'll find a "piece of DNA" for a sting as weapon, and with the points you acquired from eating food you can go to the creature generator and modify your creature. You can modify shape, color, and the position of your various parts. But if you remove any parts, you'll quickly learn that you cannot function. You *need* a mouth, eyes, and some means of propelling yourself. If you want to kill other amoeba to gain their DNA, you need some weapon, although you can finish this stage without doing that.

Once you've eaten enough food, you can evolve to the creature stage, which at first only involves adding some legs to your creature. You'll see a nice animation of your creature reaching the shore, and a summary history of your previous stage, something you'll get between any two stages in Spore. You'll quickly realize the biggest disappointment of moving from one stage to the next: Your actions and evolution of the previous stage have very little consequences on the next stage. For example when you reach the creature phase, you lose all DNA and parts you collected in the cell phase. The only consequence of the cell stage to the creature stage is a bonus ability based on whether your cell was herbivore, omnivore, or carnivore.

The creature stage is cute, and simple. Like in the cell stage you create a creature, but now in 3D, shaping a body, attaching arms, legs, eyes, mouth, and various decorations to it. The body parts give you various abilities, peaceful ones like singing, dancing, or striking a pose, or attack abilities like charge or strike. In the peaceful, herbivore version you walk over a huge landmass meeting other creatures and try to impress 3 creature of the same type for a reward. The creatures you meet are either premade from Maxis, or are creatures you created in the past, or creatures other players created and which the game downloaded via the internet. Endless possibilities, so endless that Maxis included a ban button if you encounter a walking penis. You impress them by starting communication, after which the other creature will perform one of 4 possible peaceful activities, like song or dance, and you must mimic it, doing the same activity. With advancement comes the ability to add allies, making your performances more impressive. When you impress some alpha creature, you get a piece of DNA, and other pieces can be found on animal skeletons. The DNA pieces allow you to improve your various abilities, or just decorate your creature in strange ways. In the carnivore version you attack the other creatures instead, for the same rewards. In both cases you fill up an advancement bar at the bottom of the screen, and when it is full you get to proceed to the tribal phase.

Attention! At the creature to tribal stage advancement you get a final chance to modify your creature, after that its look remains the same for the rest of the game. This is important because you might have added some features to the creature that are ugly, and you just needed them for a higher rank in something. Also, as the game expressly warns you, you should add arms to your creature at this point if you haven't done so before (they aren't strictly necessary for the creature stage). This is a completely cosmetic exercise: The abilities you collected in the creature phase are absolutely irrelevant for the following phases, you just get another bonus depending on how you played that phase. So instead of using the mouth that gives you the best singing score, you might want to use one that makes your creature look nicer, as you'll be stuck with that look. But then again that only really matters for the tribal phase, while you technically still have the same creatures in the civilization and space stage, you'll rarely ever see them.

The tribal stage is very similar to the creature stage, in that you need to either impress or suppress the other tribes. You impress them by arming your tribe with various musical instruments and play those that the other tribe requests. You suppress them by attacking them. Instead of DNA pieces you collect new buildings for your tribe, and new equipment, which again gives various stats. Besides interacting with the other tribes, you also collect food from plants or animals. Once you've done all tribes, you advance to the civilization stage.

The civilization stage is again divided into a peaceful and a military option, only now the two play the same way. Either you bombard other cities with religious messages, or you bombard them with artillery. You can construct land, air, and water vehicles, of military or religious type. The religious ones you can equip with huge organs, gongs, and megaphones to get your message across, very funny. Whatever you build in the vehicle editor comes out with health + speed + attack power = 100, you just have to decide where to put how many points in by adding the various components. Again, once you conquered by military or religion every city on the planet, you advance to the space age. At this point you get to design your space ship. It doesn't matter what you add, this is just for looks. But as you are going to fly that space ship for a very long time, you might want to make it pretty.

Finally you are in the real game, the space stage. While the previous stages can be rushed through pretty quickly, the space stage can be played near endless. In this stage Spore has a very impressive zoom function. If you zoom in to the max, your space ship hovers close to the ground on some planet, and you can see the wild creatures and plants. There are many different plants, and all the endless creations from the creature phase. You can then zoom out to the orbit, to the solar system, to the galaxy, and so far out that you see the whole galaxy before you. Which you will have to do at some point, as one of you're goals is to find the center of the galaxy, which is a lot easier with zooming out than with using the distance and angle indicator. You can zoom in and out from grass level to galaxy level, and you'll be zooming to various distances constantly throughout the game. I finally got tired using the mouse button for that, and used the CTRL+ and CTRL- keyboard shortcuts instead.

In the space stage you start with the planet you conquered in the civilization stage, which is producing one color of spice. You have a building editor to create houses, factories, and entertainment buildings, but the editor is purely cosmetic, every factory works the same. In the colony editor you place factories, houses, and entertainment buildings in every city. The more factories you place, the higher is your space production, but they also cause unhappiness. Entertainment buildings produce happiness to counter that. Houses are neutral, and produce what the buildings next to them produce. In your starting system the buildings are extremely cheap, but your spice production is rather low. You load the spice on your space ship, leave your solar system, and start exploring neighboring planets. In other solar systems you can find other civilizations, with which you can trade, form alliances, or do war. Or you can find empty systems, which you can colonize, and gather other colors of spice.

You can also do missions, at first for your own civilization, then for others, to gain their favor. The missions range from the typical Fedex "bring me something from planet X" to more complicated eradications of infected creatures somewhere, or even warfare against some other civilization. The missions for your own civilization are especially well done, because they act like some sort of tutorial, explaining you all the possible activities in the game.

Spore has a very nice achievement system, with rewards linked to your activities. You don't research new technology, you get it as reward for doing things, and what you get is connected to what you are doing. For example there are achievements related to how many solar systems you explored, and in consequence you'll get a "Frequent Flyer" badge which unlocks better drives for your space ship. Apart from achievements there are collections, so you can go hunting for sets of artifacts all over the galaxy if you want. Spore is pretty much the dream game for explorers.

In summary, I'm enjoying Spore very much, but mostly the last part, the space stage. I don't mind playing through the previous stages, because they are short enough, but in the end most of the effort you put into creating your creature is lost. Fortunately you can even skip the first 4 parts once you unlocked the space stage. The first two stages are probably suited as game even for young children. As the space stage is a very good game in its own right, I'd consider the first 4 stages just as some sort of bonus. Seen as a space 4X game, Spore is very good, and provides many hours of fun. Maybe not the revolution some people have been hoping for, but a thorough modernization of the genre. Recommended!
It sounds like a good game, but it also sounds like a very different game than what I was expecting.

Not sure what to make of that.
I'm happy to read this review.

I was happily playing the first four phases, but beyond the remarkable customization, it didn't feel like there was much *game* there. I've only been in space for about an hour, but it looks like there should be enough meat to keep me busy for a while.
I had LOT of fun in the tide pool phase (its like freeform pacman with the best bit of Evo chucked in), and in the first few iterations of the creature phase. As long as you're actively evolving new capabilities it is very satisfying to the achiever in me. Combat and social interaction for the creature were blank as heck though -- its like playing a level 4 warrior in WoW. Mash your two attacks until you taxi to victory...

The tribal phase was tedious and had tremendous penalties for failure (restart the level!) compared to the earlier two phases, which just bounced you back to home. Additionally, the difference between "I can now rejigger my creature to add FIVE ARMS ENDING WITH CLAWS OF DOOM" and "Oh, axes supplemented with SPEARS" pretty accurately represents where I find the fun.

The civilization phase is... hmm... well, there are a few things I could pick, but "fun as a game" is not one of them. I still haven't finished it.
I had a very different experience of the space stage. I found the inability of your civilization to do anything without you actively taking part really frustrating. I love 4X games, and I love exploring, but you can't explore for five minutes in Spore without your civilization calling you back to deal with pirates, an ecological disaster or some other quickly repetitive task. If you try to go see some of the other spiral arms you will be nagged constantly, and by the time you return home your civilization will be in ruins. Why can my civilization only produce one ship? why can't I hire a fleet of traders or defenders for one system? Uber turrets, Biosphere reserves, and a few other nice rewards make it easier to manage your empire, but they dont give me the freedom I want.

An economic system that doesn't require your personal constant involvment would be nice as well. At the moment there are only disadvantages in spreading farther than 15 or so solar systems, once you get your final expansion badge. Having a larger Empire gives no bonuses to anything, and due to the cap on the amount of each spice you can carry it is fairly easy to get 100 every few minutes of each of the nicer spices, and then there is no more point to expansion at all, apart from the chance to have more nagging planets to babysit. I'm happy to have extra challenges that come with a larger empire, but you would think owning a spiral arm would give you some economic or military benefit.

Don't get me wrong, I long ago passed the 50 hour achievment (Australia had a release on the 1st of Sept) and altogether I have been having a blast in this game. I love the editors, and I enjoy the other stages of the game as well, even if I agree they are a little shallow. I'm sure I'll go and further spread my empire tonight, even if the game will punish me for it. I just look and see what could have been, for me anyway, a much more enjoyable game.
The whole concept of the game is interesting, but as a gaming experience it's very disappointing.

Currently stuck at the civ phase (where you have to fight yourself, how dumb is that), as there is a decent opponent who grew as large as i did, and it'll take quite some time to convert his cities.
Thanks for the review Tobold, I was thinking of buying this game, and I'm reassured it's worth it now.
It is worth mentioning that actually, all of the pre-space stages actually impart the bonus your spacecraft receives. Whether it be a graviton wave that destroys every building on the surface, a religious conversion wave or even a "safari abductor" that quickly gathers plenty of varities animals and plants from a planets surface for your colonization efforts.

You also overlooked one thing from the Civ Stage, its entirely possible - once you gain an economic city, to simply start trade routes and buy all other cities. The civ stage also has super-powers unlocked by playing the previous stages in a certain way :).
Oh - and I forgot one OTHER thing, if you ally all other cities, or ally some and destroy/buy/convert the rest - you also win :).
Sounds like a cross between SimCity and Elite.
Ooo... I guess I should play more of the space phase! I've been mostly playing the "mini-games".

Have you been following the DRM debacle on amazon? As of right now, 1279 people have given spore a 1, almost all due to the DRM three installs limit. I thought other games have used this in the past, any idea why this bombing of spore has occurred? I go back to your thoughts about people voting with their wallets. Seems best to just not review a game you have not played, but also to not purchase a game if you disagree with their policies.
I'm not a big fan of DRM, because the pirates get around it quickly, and the honest customers are annoyed by it. Spore got cracked 1 hour after being released early in Australia, you could download it by Bittorrent a full week before it got released in the US.

But while I don't like it, I don't hate DRM so much that I won't buy any games having it. As it happens my internet went down for half an hour just while I was installing Spore, and I couldn't start the game because it requires an internet connection, which was annoying. But apart from that I don't expect much trouble from the DRM, as I don't plan to install it more than three times, or resell my disks.

It is really, really hard to say whether Spore would have sold better without DRM, or whether it would have sold less, because of some degree of "casual piracy", people "lending" their Spore disks to a friend.

Note that apart of emulated servers, MMORPGs generally don't have any DRM problems. You can't play without a valid account.
I'd like to chime in on the civ stage. You mentioned the religious and military, but not the economic. Economic domination is about bribing other nations to open trade routes. After you've opened the trade route you can simply buy the city after X amount of trading.

Also, by being economic you get a much lower chance of people trying to kill you.
I just got spore yesterday. I completed the first two stages and we NOT at liking this game. Your review gives me hope. I will still finish spore as I spent $80 on the "galactic" edition because that is all the store had.

So far my main gripe w/ spore is the lack of evolution. Evolution is all about small incremental changes. I shouldn't be able to completely change my creature in one egg. It would be more fun, and challenging if things were more limited. In the creature stage I was replacing parts every minute. Atleast make upgrades seem like I accomplished something. Perhaps this is fixed in the later 3 stages. I'll find out tonight.
I know 2 people that have Spore. One bought a legitmate copy, the other downloaded the torrent and then bought a CD key for it but is using the cracked version. The legitmate purchaser has had nothing but issues with it crashing his PC having slow start up of the game (longer than it takes to boot his PC) among other little issues. The one with the cracked version says it plays like a dream.

Now while I agree partially with what Brad said earlier about the excessive negative reviews on Amazon focusing on the draconian DRM being a bit over the top, I must disagree with him that the better method is simply not purchasing the game. EA will not even notice a few thousand people not buying the game for a title like Spore, what they will have to take notice of though is a few thousand negative reviews on a high profile site like Amazon.

Spore is the perfect title to do this for as it is so high profile, and it is about time that legitimate purchasers of the game got the better version of the title rather than the pirates. I say don't buy the game, don't pirate it, log on to Amazon and add your voice to the enraged masses let the game publishers know that the Stardock manifesto is not just online hippy claptrap but a legitimate attempt to provide a better product and service to the people who are keeping them in business.
I enjoyed reading your review. It was the review I waited for before ordering Spore. I had heard good things and bad things about the game. Your review confirmed what I had heard from both directions and made me want to play.

I ordered yesterday and the game just arrived and it is already on its way back. I have always payed for the games I played and I still get screwed over by people who believe they can make copy protection that won't be cracked.

I'll just play some other game.

It's not even the DRM that makes skip out on the game. That is bad enough.

But the game is also installing the same rootkit-type DRM software (SecuROM, on your computer that already caused a (minor?) scandal when Bioshock was released with it.

The game says on the packaging that there is copy protection but not what type.

I am very sorry about this happening I have been looking forward to Spore for a long time. I just can't support stuff like this and I feel that every single protest counts.

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home
Newer›  ‹Older

  Powered by Blogger   Free Page Rank Tool