Tobold's Blog
Thursday, November 19, 2026
 
Is it easy to make a great game?

Unlike the rest of the world, I won't be playing Grand Theft Auto VI today. Apart from the technical problem of not owning any console it would run on, I'm also not terribly interested in the game. In fact, I got Grand Theft Auto IV on Steam as part of some bundle, and Grand Theft Auto V on Epic as a free game, and haven't played either yet. I did like Grand Theft Auto: Vice City back in the days, but generally don't like games that involve driving.

Having said that, I do see that Grand Theft Auto VI has a 99% review score on Metacritic. And at this point it seems unlikely that this is some sort of hype induced illusion. GTA6 appears to be a great game, at least if you like that genre of game. Which brings me to my question: How hard is it actually to make a great game, if you have unlimited time and budget?

It could be that making a game, like making any other work of art, is inherently very hard, and it takes some special genius to make a great game. Just like it took the genius of Beethoven to make the 3rd symphony, or the genius of Leonardo da Vinci to paint the Mona Lisa. The alternative theory is that games are less about art and more about project management. If we have so many flawed games, it is because teams of developers need to produce those games within a limited time and budget. How often have we heard reviews on the release of a game that this game would have needed a bit more work, which is why the performance isn't good, or some game balance aspects haven't been properly tested. Give a group of developers 13 years time and $1+ billion, and they can easily make a great game. They just couldn't do it within the lesser time and budget given to them.

I am a bit reminded of the discussion surrounding Baldur's Gate 3, where numerous other developers said that the game had such a massive scale and time that "normal" games couldn't be expected to live up to that standard. And I guess that every gaming company CEO asking his team why they can't make a GTA6 quality game will get the answer that they *can* make that game, given the same time and money.

Is making a game like painting a work of art? Or is it more like building a house? If you rush building a house and skimp on the budget, flaws are very likely. But if you organize the house building project right, get the skilled people, and assign sufficient money and time, building a good house doesn't require a person of extraordinary genius. A reasonably competent team, all having the means to do their job right, is totally sufficient.

Comments: Post a Comment

<< Home
‹Older

  Powered by Blogger   Free Page Rank Tool